The American Revolution On The Silent Screen
It’s fascinating to see how American
silent filmmakers portrayed events from U.S. history. Just think how much
closer they were in time to events that are practically mythical to us today.
In 1915, the Civil War had taken place only 50 years prior. In 1925, the
American Revolution itself was barely reaching its 150th anniversary. And
indeed, it’s easy to find an abundance of silent Civil War films, tales from
the pioneer days, propagandistic WWI films, and of course an overwhelming
amount of silent Westerns. But what about stories from the American Revolution?
These seemed to be much fewer and farther
between, much like they still are today. Nowadays it’s easy to blame modern
filmmakers for having a simple lack of interest in Revolutionary War stories or
for audiences being less drawn to the aesthetics of powdered hair and knee
breeches. But why the sparseness way back in the silent film days? Wasn’t this a time when there was a strong
reverence for figures like George Washington and organizations like the
Daughters of the American Revolution were very well-known?

in Picture-Play magazine.
Perhaps we can point to a few reasons. In
cinema’s earliest days, the 1890s-1900s, films were very focused on
contemporary events. The excitement over capturing “life as it really was”
meant cameramen were quick to capture parades, military drills, footage of
famous figures, street scenes, and any other contemporary events they could
reach with their cameras. By the 1910s short fictional stories had grown in
popularity, as did reenactments of historical events, yet Revolutionary War
films were still relatively rare. Perhaps the 18th century costuming was a
drawback for most studios with meager budgets.
It’s probable, too, that both filmmakers
and their audiences had grown up enamored with Civil War stories and were more
excited to see them on the screen. More than a few likely had fathers,
grandfathers and other relatives who’d actually fought in the conflict. And
then there’s the timing: as the film industry matured throughout the 1910s and
epic battle scenes were growing more common, WWI started. Films with negative
depictions of our British allies were, shall we say, frowned upon. By the
1920s, fatigue from the four-year Great War and a surging interest in all
things modern perhaps meant that audiences were less interested in
wigs-and-muskets tales.
With all that said, what are some
prominent examples of silent Revolutionary War films? What kinds of stories did
filmmakers find exciting or of enough importance to try to immortalize in film?
The Hessian Renegades (1909)

From 1908 to 1914, director D.W. Griffith
made an astonishing 500 short films for the American Biograph Company. Aside
from the plethora of dramatic stories, short romances, and even comedies, he
would sometimes tackle subjects that drew from history. The Hessian
Renegades told the story of a father who seeks revenge for the death of his
son, an army dispatcher who’s killed by German mercenaries (“Hessian”). While
the acting may seem stilted to our eyes, it’s done with sincerity and an eye
towards the seriousness of the high-stakes story. As a bonus, it features Mary
Pickford–then new to films–who disguises herself as a mercenary.
The Heart of a Hero (1916)

This feature told the dramatic story of
Nathan Hale, he of the “I only regret that I have but one life to give for my
country” quote fame. It was based on the 1898 play Nathan Hale by Clyde
Fitch, the most popular American playwright at that point in time. It includes
one of those obligatory romances–in this case between Hale and his student–and
a solemn outdoor death sequence. Directed with care and featuring costumes
reportedly based on authentic 18th century clothing, it was praised for the
respectful way it treated historic events but was also criticized by Moving
Picture World for having a French, rather than American, director.
Betsy Ross (1917)

This
if very fictionalized, feature stars Alice Brady as the famed maker of
the first official U.S. flag. Much of the film centers upon Betsy’s rivalry
with her sister over the affections of a British officer. Eventually there is a
duel, both Betsy and her sister end up marrying different men, Betsy starts a
small business, and she eventually gets suspected of harboring a spy (it all
seems a bit off topic). We also see her receive her commission from George
Washington himself to create the first American flag. This was made by the
World Film Company in Fort Lee, New Jersey, one of the dwindling number of
studios still making films on the East coast rather than sunny southern
California.
Janice Meredith (1924)

This Marion Davies costume drama,
well-funded by her significant other William Randolph Hearst, was not a major
hit but did respectably well. It followed the exploits of the lively Janice
Meredith, a Tory girl who flirts with both Americans and the British. She just
happens to become involved in assisting Paul Revere on his famous ride and even
George Washington during his fateful crossing of the Delaware. Marie Antoinette
and Benjamin Franklin also make appearances. The lengthy film tried to be a bit
of everything–dramatic, humorous, even a bit artsy. It also featured a
character played by W.C. Fields, his first 1920s film role, and the silent era
Harrison FordC.
America (1924)

In the 1920s, D.W. Griffith was hoping to
create an epic film that would do for the American Revolution what his weighty The
Birth of a Nation (1915) did for the Civil War. Lengthy and ambitiously
presented, it jumped between both Patriot and Loyalist viewpoints and depicted
many famous incidents such as the Battle of Bunker Hill and the Siege of
Yorktown. Spies, Indian attacks, and large-scale battle scenes abound. While
less controversial than his 1915 Civil War epic and certainly big on
battlefield spectacle, plot points floated confusingly between various
characters and critics felt the film was out of step with what was popular at
the time. Nonetheless it makes for interesting viewing today, especially around
any Fourth of July.
…
–Lea Stans for Classic Movie Hub
You can read all of Lea’s Silents are Golden articles here.
Lea Stans is a born-and-raised Minnesotan with a degree in English and an obsessive interest in the silent film era (which she largely blames on Buster Keaton). In addition to blogging about her passion at her site Silent-ology, she is a columnist for the Silent Film Quarterly and has also written for The Keaton Chronicle.
–






