Silver Screen Standards: Storms and Silence in The Spiral Staircase (1946)

Silver Screen Standards: Storms and Silence in The Spiral Staircase (1946)

Gothic atmosphere churns tempestuously in Robert
Siodmak’s 1946 mystery, The Spiral Staircase, with a terrific storm in
the natural world that mirrors the psychological turbulence experienced by both
heroine and killer. This moody, tense thriller teems with menace as an elusive
murderer stalks women with disabilities, but its protagonist, played to great
effect by Dorothy McGuire, is no mere victim, despite her inability to speak.
Ethel Barrymore gives a particularly rich performance as the ailing matriarch
of the fractious Warren family, but the supporting cast is full of iconic
players, including George Brent, Kent Smith, Rhonda Fleming, Elsa Lanchester,
and Sara Allgood. A true classic, The Spiral Staircase rewards repeat
visits once its central mystery has been revealed, leaving the viewer free to
appreciate the themes and performances that elevate the whole beyond the old
dark house genre with which it shares many of its foundational elements.

McGuire stars as the silent but capable Helen, a young
woman left unable to speak after an earlier traumatic event. Helen works as a
companion to the elderly, temperamental Mrs. Warren (Ethel Barrymore), who
begins to fear for Helen’s safety as disabled young women in the town turn up
murdered one after another. Mrs. Warren’s affection for Helen is countered by
her disappointment in the younger Warrens, both her stepson, Professor Albert Warren
(George Brent), and her feckless biological son, Steve (Gordon Oliver), who has
returned to the house after a long absence. While Helen attends to Mrs. Warren,
the half-brothers clash constantly, especially over Steve’s romantic pursuit of
Albert’s secretary, Blanche (Rhonda Fleming). Helen’s suitor, Dr. Parry (Kent
Smith), wants to get her away from the Warren house in the belief that
specialists in Boston might be able to restore her speech, but his patients and
the weather conspire to delay Helen’s departure until a violent storm traps her
in the house where a killer lies in wait.

The storm makes plenty of noise throughout the movie,
but silence also has power, as McGuire’s emotive performance proves. In many
ways it’s a throwback to the silent era, with Helen communicating through
gestures and body language instead of speech. We first see her attending a
silent film screening, which helps to set the era of the story but also
prepares us for McGuire’s performance. In every scene, McGuire keeps us focused
on her heroine without a single line of dialogue, no mean feat in a movie where
everyone else talks. Helen constantly reveals her lively nature, intelligence,
and sense of humor, and she’s never a passive victim or less than a fully
fledged individual. She handles Mrs. Warren with grace and patience, daydreams
about marrying Dr. Parry, and fights for her life when the killer strikes. Of
course, Helen’s forced silence is a crucial plot point because it prevents her
from calling out for help or using the telephone, and it’s her difference that
attracts the deranged killer in the first place. Dr. Parry’s obsession with curing
her seems overbearing and even cruel at times, his excuse being that her
silence is purely psychological and not physical, but modern perspectives on
disability and ableism push back against the idea that Helen needs Dr. Parry to
“fix” her. That critique also exists within the movie, as Steve Warren actually
questions the doctor’s actions, while the insane killer views women like Helen
as deserving of death merely because of their disabilities.

In addition to Helen’s psychological trauma, the movie
also probes the causes and effects of the emotional trauma experienced by the
two Warren sons, both of whom were disappointments to their hypermasculine
father. Helen’s childhood suffering when her family died in a fire was acute
and sudden, but Albert and Steve have endured years of emotional neglect and
abuse, and both are damaged by it. Although the late Mr. Warren despised his
sons for their perceived “weakness,” Mrs. Warren perpetuates the abuse in her
treatment of the two men, proving that mothers can be dangerous advocates for
toxic masculinity, too. Throughout the house there are symbols of this deadly
heritage in the form of hunting trophies, especially tigers, all of them
emphasizing a “kill or be killed” attitude toward strength and power. The
troubled history of the Warren family casts a Gothic gloom over the house akin
to that of the House of Usher or Wuthering Heights, and it gives Mrs. Warren’s
warnings to Helen a palpable sense of urgency. Nothing good can happen in this
house full of secrets, shadows, and festering wounds, and the building violence
eventually breaks open like the storm raging overhead. The titular spiral
staircase, a central feature of the Warren house, suggests the twisted hearts
that lie at the center of the story, and we repeatedly see women carrying
candles as they descend into the psychological underworld embodied by the
mansion’s dark cellars. What – and who – they find at the bottom reveals the
extent to which the elder Warrens’ sins have come home to roost. This densely
packed symbolism really merits repeated viewings of the picture so that every
detail and subtle motif can be fully appreciated.

Don’t try to figure out the killer’s identity based on the eye repeatedly seen in closeup; that voyeuristic orb belongs to director Robert Siodmak himself. You can see more of Siodmak’s work, if not his eye, in Phantom Lady (1944), The Suspect (1944), The Killers (1946), and Criss Cross (1949). Dorothy McGuire also stars in The Enchanted Cottage (1945), A Tree Grows in Brooklyn (1945), and Gentlemen’s Agreement (1947). Stage legend Ethel Barrymore earned her second Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actress for her role in The Spiral Staircase, having already won the award for None but the Lonely Heart (1944). She would be nominated again for The Paradine Case (1947) and Pinky (1949), but I also really like her in the lesser-known Moss Rose (1947). For a thematic double feature, try pairing The Spiral Staircase with Johnny Belinda (1948), Wait Until Dark (1967), or even the 2018 Best Picture winner, The Shape of Water (2017).

…

— Jennifer Garlen for Classic Movie Hub

Jennifer Garlen pens our monthly Silver Screen Standards column. You can read all of Jennifer’s Silver Screen Standards articles here.

Jennifer is a former college professor with a PhD in English Literature and a lifelong obsession with film. She writes about classic movies at her blog, Virtual Virago, and presents classic film programs for lifetime learning groups and retirement communities. She’s the author of Beyond Casablanca: 100 Classic Movies Worth Watching and its sequel, Beyond Casablanca II: 101 Classic Movies Worth Watching, and she is also the co-editor of two books about the works of Jim Henson.