Supportive Fellas of Film Noir: Part II

Supportive Fellas of Film Noir: Part II

More than a year ago, I
started a series, “Supportive Fellas of Film Noir,” which focused on  . . . well . . . the supporting male characters
in film noir features. It’s been a while since I promised to shine the
spotlight on these gents, so I figured there was no time like the present to
take another deep dive into this shadowy, supportive pool. This month’s Noir
Nook will take a look at three more of my favorites: Jeff Hartnett, Whit
Sterling, and Wally Fay.

…..

Jeff Hartnett in Johnny Eager (1942)

Robert Taylor stars in
the title role of a smooth ex-con who drives a taxi to cover for a spate of criminal
enterprises, from operating an illegal dog racing track to committing stone-cold
murder. His circle of friends and lovers includes Garnet (Patricia Dane), his
sometime-girlfriend; Lisbeth Bard (Lana Turner), the stepdaughter of Johnny’s
nemesis in the D.A.’s office; and Jeff Hartnett, Johnny’s right-hand man
(played by Best Supporting Actor Oscar winner Van Heflin).

Shortly after we make
Jeff’s acquaintance, we learn three things about him: (1) he’s an intellectual,
with a sensitive soul and a penchant for quoting Shakespeare, (2) he’s
unutterably devoted to Johnny, and (3) he’s a functional alcoholic. We’re not
told in so many words, but we get the impression that his reliance on the
bottle is somehow tied in with the other two factoids about him – his
allegiance to Johnny and his ties to Johnny’s criminal activities seem to be in
direct conflict with his intelligence and his sense of right and wrong. In
fact, when once asked by Johnny why he drinks so much, Jeff responds, “Every
now and then I’ve got to look in a mirror.”

Don’t get me wrong – Jeff was Johnny’s closest friend and most loyal supporter, but he could also be unflinchingly honest when it came to Johnny’s actions and beliefs, regardless of the potential consequences. In the most extreme case of this, in one scene, Jeff makes a reference to Johnny’s self-centered nature and winds up on the floor with a sore jaw. But while Jeff departed that encounter with a final-sounding, “That broke it,” there was nothing Johnny could do to make Jeff truly abandon him. We could all do with a Jeff in our lives.

…..

Whit Sterling in Out
of the Past (1947)

In this acclaimed noir
feature, Robert Mitchum is Jeff Bailey, a small-town service station owner
whose past as a private investigator (with a different last name) comes back to
bite him when he has a chance encounter with a former associate. His past
includes racketeer Whit Sterling (Kirk Douglas) and Kathie Moffat (Jane Greer),
the alluring dame who Sterling was desperate to find after she shot him and
stole a cool forty grand.

Whit is a fascinating
character – a refined gangster with a well-modulated voice and a pleasant smile.
But he’s scary, too. When we first meet him, in a flashback where he’s hiring
Jeff to track down Kathie, Whit is friendly, mild-mannered – he even doesn’t
seem to be angry at Kathie. He just wants her back in his life.  But when Jeff asks him what he’ll do to
Kathie when she returns, Whit’s eyes grow cold as he responds, “I won’t touch
her.” It’s a chilling moment – and it’s not the last where Whit’s concerned.

In fact, almost every time we see Whit – and it’s not often – he has an air of affability that sets your teeth on edge. You never know what he’s going to say or do. You can ‘t figure him out. You don’t know if you should trust what he’s saying or head for the hills. Take the scene where he surprises Jeff by showing up in Mexico, where Jeff has found (and fallen for) Kathie. Whit doesn’t know that, but we’re not quite sure what he does know. Is he really just in Mexico to “see a man about a horse”? Is he in town to check up on his private dick investment? Or does he suspect that Jeff knows more than he’s telling? The suspense is lethal.

…..

Wally Fay in Mildred
Pierce (1945)

In this feature, Joan
Crawford stars in the title role of a single mother who will stop at almost
nothing to earn the regard of her impossibly supercilious daughter, Veda (Ann
Blyth). After the bust-up of her marriage to Bert (Bruce Bennett), Mildred
takes a waitressing job to make ends meet, but eventually hits the jackpot with
a chain of successful restaurants. She comes to learn, though, that money
doesn’t buy happiness. Or devotion. Or love. And sometimes, it leads to murder.
The cast is rounded out by Mildred’s cash-poor second husband Monte Beragon
(Zachary Scott); Mildred’s saucy best pal, Ida Corwin (Eve Arden); and Bert
Pierce’s former real estate partner, Wally Fay (Jack Carson).

On the surface, Wally
was a jokester, a good-time Charlie who was always quick with a quip. But like
Whit Sterling, his exterior was far different than what was underneath. We
learn this early on, when Mildred’s voiceover references the end of the
partnership between her husband and Wally: “One day they split up. Wally was in
and Bert was out. They weren’t partners anymore. That day when Bert came home,
he was out of a job.” We don’t find out any of the specifics, but we get the
distinct impression that loyalty was not one of Wally’s strong suits, and
self-preservation was.

We see this throughout
the film – Wally is always (and I mean always) looking out for number one. When
he finds out that Mildred and Bert are separated, he doesn’t waste any time trying
to replace his former friend (“I’ve always been soft in the head where you’re
concerned . . . maybe there’s a chance for me now.”). When Veda secretly
marries her well-to-do boyfriend, it’s Wally who brokers a hefty financial
settlement to end the union and, of course, plans to get his piece of the pie.
And when Mildred’s business faces a financial crisis, Wally is the one who
lands on his feet. And, yet, there’s something about Wally that prevents us
from being mad at him – it’s not his fault that he consistently puts himself
first. He does it with such charm! (Whaddya gonna do?)

——

Stay tuned for future Noir Nooks, where I’ll explore more first-rate supporting gents – and the ladies, too!

…

– Karen Burroughs Hannsberry for Classic Movie Hub

You can read all of Karen’s Noir Nook articles here.

Karen Burroughs Hannsberry is the author of the Shadows and Satin blog, which focuses on movies and performers from the film noir and pre-Code eras, and the editor-in-chief of The Dark Pages, a bimonthly newsletter devoted to all things film noir. Karen is also the author of two books on film noir – Femme Noir: The Bad Girls of Film and Bad Boys: The Actors of Film Noir. You can follow Karen on Twitter at @TheDarkPages.
If you’re interested in learning more about Karen’s books, you can read more about them on amazon here: